What Makes Us Different?

Our agency’s professional staff truly cares about serving people who have been called into ministry. Our knowledge, training, and personal experience make us uniquely qualified to understand your needs and help you protect every aspect of your ministry operation.

What Customers Say

American Church Group of New England and Brotherhood Mutual have provided our growing church with excellent customer service from the very start of our relationship. Our agent knows us and our needs, and when we had to make a claim, the process was straightforward and professional. I cannot imagine getting better service from an insurance company.

Daniel King, Next Level Church

Need to
Get in Touch
with Us?

Whether you are shopping for insurance or need help with your existing policy, we're here to help. We welcome the opportunity to get to know you and your ministry better!

Connect with Us

From Our Blog

Thoughts, advice & information.

  • Read More Guidance for Ministries About Boy Scouts' Bankruptcy
    Guidance for Ministries About Boy Scouts' Bankruptcy
  • Read More Applying for PPP Loan Forgiveness
    Applying for PPP Loan Forgiveness
  • Read More UPDATED: CARES Act: Churches Need to Apply Now
    UPDATED: CARES Act: Churches Need to Apply Now
  • Read More Coronavirus and Your Ministry: Tips for Prevention
    Coronavirus and Your Ministry: Tips for Prevention
  • Read More Hosting a Game Day Bash? Brush Up on Copyright Basics
    Hosting a Game Day Bash? Brush Up on Copyright Basics
  • Read More Are You Covered If You're Injured Overseas?
    Are You Covered If You're Injured Overseas?
  • Read More IRS Announces More Church Audits Regarding ACA Compliance
    IRS Announces More Church Audits Regarding ACA Compliance
  • Read More Celebrate Safely This Independence Day
    Celebrate Safely This Independence Day
  • Read More Insurance is one of those things we forget about until we need it
    Insurance is one of those things we forget about until we need it
  • Read More May 5-11 is Hurricane Preparedness Week
    May 5-11 is Hurricane Preparedness Week
  • Read More Measles Cases Reach Record-Breaking Numbers
    Measles Cases Reach Record-Breaking Numbers
  • Read More Vehicle Registration Guidelines for Ministries
    Vehicle Registration Guidelines for Ministries
  • Read More June Is National Safety Month - Week 1: Emergency Preparedness
    June Is National Safety Month - Week 1: Emergency Preparedness
  • Read More Collect Online Donations? This New Scam Targets You
    Collect Online Donations? This New Scam Targets You
  • Read More Remembering Billy Graham
    Remembering Billy Graham
  • Read More Flu Is Widespread: Protect Your Congregation
    Flu Is Widespread: Protect Your Congregation
  • Read More Off-Site Youth Activities
    Off-Site Youth Activities
  • Read More Insurance Protection Should Accompany Every Mission Trip
    Insurance Protection Should Accompany Every Mission Trip
  • Read More Think Before You Loan Your Ministry's Vehicles
    Think Before You Loan Your Ministry's Vehicles
  • Read More Has Your Church Completed a Personal Property Inventory?
    Has Your Church Completed a Personal Property Inventory?
  • Read More Is Your Ministry as Safe as It Could Be?
    Is Your Ministry as Safe as It Could Be?
  • Read More Health Care Reimbursement Option Now Available
    Health Care Reimbursement Option Now Available
  • Read More IRS Warns of Dangerous W-2 Email Scam
    IRS Warns of Dangerous W-2 Email Scam
  • Read More Dual Tax Status: What Does It Mean for Your Pastor?
    Dual Tax Status: What Does It Mean for Your Pastor?
  • Read More Protect Your Board Against Lawsuits
    Protect Your Board Against Lawsuits
  • Read More Incorporation Can Protect Church Members
    Incorporation Can Protect Church Members
  • Read More How Well Does Your Ministry Secure Personal Data?
    How Well Does Your Ministry Secure Personal Data?
  • Read More Keep Would-Be Thieves from Curbing your Christmas Joy
    Keep Would-Be Thieves from Curbing your Christmas Joy
  • Read More Are Your Church Christmas Decorations a Fire Hazard
    Are Your Church Christmas Decorations a Fire Hazard
  • Read More Always Looking for Church Nursery Volunteers?
    Always Looking for Church Nursery Volunteers?
  • Read More Take Steps to Prevent the Flu
    Take Steps to Prevent the Flu
  • Read More Safety Makes for an Enjoyable Hayride
    Safety Makes for an Enjoyable Hayride
  • Read More New Overtime Ruling Takes Effect in December
    New Overtime Ruling Takes Effect in December
  • Read More Ministries Can Take Steps to Protect their Beliefs
    Ministries Can Take Steps to Protect their Beliefs
  • Read More Take the Confusion out of Borrowing or Leasing Vehicles
    Take the Confusion out of Borrowing or Leasing Vehicles
  • Read More Knowing the Terms Can Help You Understand Your Auto Policy
    Knowing the Terms Can Help You Understand Your Auto Policy
  • Read More Reduce the Likelihood of Sexual Misconduct in a Counseling Setting
    Reduce the Likelihood of Sexual Misconduct in a Counseling Setting
  • Read More Improper Texts: Guard Against the Harm They Cause
    Improper Texts: Guard Against the Harm They Cause
  • Read More If You Build It, Risks Will Come
    If You Build It, Risks Will Come
  • Read More Take Precautions to Prevent Child Abuse
    Take Precautions to Prevent Child Abuse
  • Read More Is Pikachu Hiding Under a Pew Near You?
    Is Pikachu Hiding Under a Pew Near You?
  • Read More Boating Safety: Remain Vigilant while on the Water
    Boating Safety: Remain Vigilant while on the Water
  • Read More Water Inflatables: Be Safe and Have Fun
    Water Inflatables: Be Safe and Have Fun
  • Read More Swim Safety: Help Your Group Enjoy a Day in the Sun
    Swim Safety: Help Your Group Enjoy a Day in the Sun
  • Read More Does Your Pastor Really Have 99 Kids?
    Does Your Pastor Really Have 99 Kids?
  • Read More Protect Your Board Members
    Protect Your Board Members
  • Read More Cyber Liability Issues
    Cyber Liability Issues
  • Read More Planning Your International Missions Trip
    Planning Your International Missions Trip
  • Read More Housing Disaster Victims
    Housing Disaster Victims
  • Read More Protect Your Ministry with Adequate Disaster Planning
    Protect Your Ministry with Adequate Disaster Planning
  • Read More Vehicle Management is Safety Management
    Vehicle Management is Safety Management
  • Read More Income Tax Results Made You Sick? It's Time for a Checkup.
    Income Tax Results Made You Sick? It's Time for a Checkup.
  • Read More How to Report a Claim
    How to Report a Claim
  • Read More Understanding Your Property-Casualty Insurance Policy
    Understanding Your Property-Casualty Insurance Policy
  • Read More Training a Church Safety Team
    Training a Church Safety Team
  • Read More April is Triple Tax-Deadline Month for Many Ministries
    April is Triple Tax-Deadline Month for Many Ministries
  • Read More Mission Trips: More Than
    Mission Trips: More Than "Just Do It" Situations
  • Read More How to Buy Church Insurance
    How to Buy Church Insurance
  • Read More Religion, Politics, and the Tax Code
    Religion, Politics, and the Tax Code
  • Read More Sorting Through Mission Travel Insurance
    Sorting Through Mission Travel Insurance
  • Read More Prepare Now for Spring Storms
    Prepare Now for Spring Storms
  • Read More Top 5 Things Your Ministry Should Know About the Zika Virus
    Top 5 Things Your Ministry Should Know About the Zika Virus
  • Read More Handle Church Money with Intentional Care
    Handle Church Money with Intentional Care
  • Read More How to Pay Church Employees
    How to Pay Church Employees
  • Read More Preparing for a Meeting with Your Agent
    Preparing for a Meeting with Your Agent
  • Read More Protecting Staff Members Is a 'Must Do' for Churches
    Protecting Staff Members Is a 'Must Do' for Churches
  • Read More Save Lives with a Church Medical Response Team
    Save Lives with a Church Medical Response Team
  • Read More Financial Red Flags and Proactive Practices
    Financial Red Flags and Proactive Practices
  • Read More Ten Ways to Help Prevent Electrical Fires at Church
    Ten Ways to Help Prevent Electrical Fires at Church
  • Read More 7 Steps to Reduce the Risk of Frozen Pipes
    7 Steps to Reduce the Risk of Frozen Pipes
  • Read More Defending Your Digital Presence
    Defending Your Digital Presence
  • Read More Why Your Directors and Officers Care About Insurance
    Why Your Directors and Officers Care About Insurance

View All Posts

News & Events

Virtual Christian School Finance Summit November 10

Take your School’s Budget from Burden to Blessing

This daylong summit is designed for administrative teams focused on improving financial well-being in a way that aligns with your school’s mission. This lineup of experts explores key challenges Christian schools are facing, as well as strategy, new ideas, and best practices for financial sustainability, donor engagement, enrollment, and more.

Register Today

September 11, 2020
Brotherhood Mutual Customers to Receive a Premium Credit

Serving the Church is more important than ever during this unique time in history. That’s why Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company is taking steps to help ministries as they continue to adjust to a new normal that includes finding creative ways to keep people connected to each other and the gospel.

The company is helping customers across the nation by applying a 15% credit on two months of liability premium on their Brotherhood Mutual Auto and Commercial Multi-Peril policies in effect on April 15, 2020.

The credit will be applied as the company receives approval from each state. Customers will not have to do anything to receive the credit. It will be automatically applied to your policy when our state’s approval comes through.

Questions? Read the full article on Brotherhood Mutual’s website.